How I Met Your Mother just wrapped up its season 8 finale by pulling a "Classic Schmosby," as Punchy would say. The show revealed something they know the audience is dying to see to cover up their terrible writing in both the plot and the jokes.
Marshall and Lily start off the episodes with packing up their belongings for the move to Rome. A lot of the jokes and content between Lily and Marshall were things that could have been placed in The King of Queens, or Everybody Loves Raymond, or some other family sitcom no one respects. These same jokes continued when Marshall went to Minnesota to smooth things over with his mother, only to receive a call saying that his application to be a judge has gone through. It's almost embarrassing to see the writers try to make the audience care about Marshall and Lily. These are two characters who have been absolutely pointless and useless throughout most of their existence. Once the baby was born, they became even more useless. Their whole idea of moving to Rome is about as farfetched as the idea of Marshall being a Judge, since we've seen him go to trial once during this entire series.Also, how does Marshall have two or three brothers, but none of them were in his wedding party?
Meanwhile, Robin and Barney are celebrating their completion of every wedding task, including the over the top dance number planned as their first wedding dance (it involves confetti). Their celebration dinner is ruined by the appearance of Casey Wilson and that one guy from Key and Peele. There could be more detail in the plot line with Robin and Barney trying to sabotage Casey Wilson's relationship, but it is completely pointless. It has absolutely no relevance. So useless, it felt like something that could have been thrown in mid-season. Barney and Robin are supposed to be getting married in a week, yet the writers have these two characters doing absolutely nothing. They're supposed to be the focal point of how the next season turns out. It's all riding on what happens to Robin and Barney, not Ted. There was no conflict between the two in the finale, yet the creators have been teasing conflict for this wedding for the past three seasons, which isn't an exaggeration. There wasn't a single joke in the finale that would make a normal person laugh out loud, besides Robin talking about shoving things in her butt because, well, butts are kind of funny. Robin was featured more in the show, but al in flashbacks.
Lily plays a more prominent role in this season then she has for a while now. Ted and Lily go to the house, which results in Ted revealing he is going to sell the infamous house his kids are supposed to grow up in and move to Chicago. Lily is enjoying being at the house, since the internet-less and cable-less apartment is like "Little House on the freaking Prairie." While Ted reveals that Marshall love his waffles, which include cinnamon, he mentions his heartache in not finding his wife yet, while watching his one true love marry his best friend. Ted and Robin failed in finding her necklace/locket thing in Central Park in the previous episode, only to reveal that Robin was drunk and dug it up years ago. Apparently, Robin and Lily dug up the necklace/locket in season 4 when she was depressed Ted was marrying Stella and not her. This past season did do a good job showing how much Ted really wants to be with Robin, regardless of anything he might do to cover up that sign. HIMYM turned Ted and Robin into a version of Ross and Rachel, but with the promise they're not going to be together.
Also, Ted is taking the train home from the wedding, the mother is at the train station, blah blah blah, stuff that no one really cares about.
The audience knows what happens to Ted, regardless of anything that is thrown in the way. Ted gets with the Mother, who is now officially played by Cristin Milioti, doesn't move to Chicago, doesn't sell the house, and does typical Robin nonsense. Barney has been set up for the past three seasons to debate over whether or not he wants to marry Robin, yet he has been relatively fine for most of the season. The previous episode put in on real thick with the rain and the holding hands between Robin and Ted, yet Robin barely did anything in this finale.
The show has now officially ran into the problem they knew they would run into: there is nowhere to go with any character. They have backed themselves into a corner where there is nothing to anticipate, therefore, the audience immediately loses interest. Unless there is an actual plot twist within this final season where some thing major happens in the Barney/Robin/Ted storyline, no one will care. There was legit shocked when HIMYM revealed the mother for the very first time, but that was the only thing consistent and interesting in the episode. The reveal was going to happen at some point in time. Whoever plans the overall story arc of the season has been absolutely inconsistent, almost like they don't even remember their own show.
How I Met Your Mother has set it up to the point where if Robin ends up with someone other than Ted, no one will care. Robin has been shaped and molded, since she really has no consistent character direction, to be the girl Ted should be with. The writers have one season to explain to the audience why the Mother was worth Ted's pain and suffering and that monologue at the end of that time traveling episode where Ted cries and spills his guts out doesn't count. It's not that the reveal of the Mother wasn't important, it's just that HIMYM set it up to where her reveal had no pop or flare. It was a dud. Let's see if Craig Thomas and Carter Bays have the balls to swerve the audience and make Robin and Ted be together somehow, because they clearly do not care about the Mother.





